Back to openDemocracy Email us Powered by TypePad  
political magazine Help bring democracy to the US
political magazine The New oD Today
political magazine China's modernisation and its discontents
political magazine openDemocracy widget
political magazine Goodbye Habeas Corpus
political magazine Dance the guns to silence?
political magazine Don't be a lawyer in China
political magazine Have we hit the ground yet?
political magazine The strange ways of Falungong
political magazine 2000 dead
political magazine April 2006
political magazine December 2005
political magazine November 2005
political magazine October 2005
political magazine September 2005
political magazine August 2005
political magazine July 2005
political magazine June 2005
political magazine May 2005
political magazine April 2005
My Photo oD Today
A weblog from the editors, staff and friends of openDemocracy.net

« Katrina pledge | Main | Yahoo sends Chinese journalist to Prison »

Accountability is not a blame game

Accountability is not, as President Bush has described it, a “blame game”. It is a fundamental requirement of a functioning democracy. With his announcement that he himself would lead the investigation into Hurricane Katrina, President Bush moved this week’s events from tragedy to farce. To investigate a set of events in which his own administration has received more criticism than followed either 9/11 or the war in Iraq, given this administration’s track record on deflecting criticism and distorting public truth, is to add mockery to the misery of the victims.

Katrina has exposed so many questions about the US state, the condition of its government and the hidden costs of ideological hostility to the idea of government responsibility, that it is hard to know where to begin. But begin the US must, with an independent inquiry that has the powers to demand evidence and reach firm conclusions.

If the many allegations about budget cuts, lack of preparedness and slow and chaotic response are accurate, then work must begin now to protect potential victims of future catastrophic events. Events of the scale of Hurricane Katrina are mercifully rare, but catastrophes are not all that unusual. Regardless of the party affiliation of those responsible for the appalling story of New Orleans, the administration has a clear public duty to ensure such bungling never happens again. George W Bush is not the man to lead that effort.

In Egypt this week, a fire tragically took the lives of 13 young students locked in a theatre. When the bodies were removed to the morgue, armed guards beat back relatives who were desperate for news of their loved ones. As one reporter wrote:

"This was a human calamity, a summer theatre festival for university students that ended with the deaths of 13 young people from one theatre troupe alone, and the government's primary response was to focus on security."

From New Orleans, we hear the same complaint: that the federal government sent more troops than doctors, more guns than medical supplies. And in another curious echo of events in Louisiana, an Egyptian protester identified the cause:

"We're very, very tired," Mr. Izat yelled. "We're very, very poor. They don't care about us."

September 7, 2005 | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83454872c69e200d83554267a69e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Accountability is not a blame game:



Comments

The comments to this entry are closed.

Back to openDemocracy Email us Powered by TypePad